Choosing An AI SEO Agency: What To Look For Before You Hire

choosing an ai seo agency 12270b12
Ask questions about this post:

Most shortlists start in a directory. That is the first mistake. The aim here is for you to judge agencies yourself, the same way Victoria Olsina does in Victoria Olsina’s guide to choosing a technical SEO agency.

What to look for in an AI SEO agency

Start with what breaks. An agency layers AI tactics onto a site Google cannot crawl properly, and nothing it publishes gets indexed, let alone cited.

AI search visibility sits on top of classic SEO. It does not replace it.

Technical SEO foundations

Ask how the agency checks crawlability, indexation, internal linking and schema. A serious team works from Search Console and GA4 data, not a generic audit tool export.

LLMs and Google both read structure. Weak on-page SEO means weak signals everywhere.

Takeaway: no technical audit, no deal.

A repeatable AI search method

The agency should explain how it tests whether your brand appears in ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google’s AI answers. Expect a defined set of prompts, regular citation checks and a record of which pages get cited.

If the method sounds vague, it probably is. Compare their answer with how specialists describe LLM SEO.

Takeaway: ask to see the prompt set they would track for you.

Control over AI-assisted content

AI content systems can produce volume fast. Volume without editing produces thin pages, factual errors and duplicate angles.

Ask who edits, who fact-checks and how automation is gated. A sound setup looks like a documented workflow, similar to the one described in this AI content automation case study.

Takeaway: every automated step needs a named human owner.

Reporting tied to pipeline

Rankings and impressions are inputs. Founders care about qualified traffic, sign-ups and pipeline.

Ask which conversions the agency reports on and how often. Good reporting connects Search Console queries and AI citations to GA4 conversion events.

Takeaway: if the report stops at rankings, push back.

Fit with your sector

Regulated or technical sectors need writers and strategists who understand the product. A FinTech brand faces compliance review. A Web3 brand faces a sceptical, technical audience.

Sector fit cuts revision cycles. Victoria Olsina’s guide to choosing a FinTech SEO agency looks at that sector.

Takeaway: ask for sector-specific examples, not general claims.

A vetting table you can use on the first call

Marketer interviewing an agency on a first discovery call

Use this table as a script. Ask each question, listen, then compare the answer with the failure case.

CriterionWhat a good answer sounds likeFailure case
Technical SEO base“We start with a crawl, Search Console and GA4, then fix indexation and schema before content.”“We will start publishing in week one.”
AI search method“We track a fixed prompt set in ChatGPT and Perplexity and log citations monthly.”“AI search is just good SEO, nothing changes.”
Content and automation controls––
Reporting“We report qualified sessions, conversions and cited pages against your pipeline goals.”“You will get a ranking report.”
Fit with your sector––

Semrush’s agency directory lists dozens of UK AI search optimisation agencies and sorts them by its own agency score.

RevenueBase ranks London AI SEO agencies by professional contacts tracked, largest first. That measures headcount, not outcomes.

A big team is not a good team. A long listing is not a track record.

Takeaway: ignore directory order and run every agency through the table.

UK agencies to check against the criteria

agencies.semrush.com page screenshot

These picks are not ranked. Each appears in a public UK directory listing, and they are judged only on how they describe themselves. Verify every claim on the call.

Victoria Olsina Growth Marketing Consultancy

Victoria Olsina Growth Marketing Consultancy specialises in AI search and SEO for crypto, Web3, fintech and AI companies. Victoria Olsina leads every engagement herself and is the author of Mastering AI Search for Crypto & Web3 Brands. Published results include a 12x increase in Book a Demo leads for Notabene and $1.75M in influenced pipeline at ConsenSys, where she was Head of SEO. Her AI SEO and GEO service covers entity work, content built for extraction and AI visibility tracking.

Best for: regulated or technical brands that need to be cited in AI answers, not just ranked on Google.

Suso Digital

Suso Digital appears in RevenueBase’s list of London AI SEO agencies. A listing tells you it exists and markets SEO services, nothing more.

Against the criteria, ask for its AI search method and a sample technical audit first.

SKALE

SKALE also appears in RevenueBase’s London list. Its position there reflects contacts tracked, not results.

Test its reporting answer hardest. Ask how it links organic work to pipeline for your sector.

Growth Partners Media

Growth Partners Media appears in the Semrush UK AI search optimisation directory. Treat that as a starting point only.

Ask for its content controls: who edits, who fact-checks and what gets automated.

Finixio

Finixio describes itself in RevenueBase as a UK-based, remote-first marketing and SEO agency working with clients worldwide. Remote delivery suits some founders and frustrates others.

Check sector fit and ask how it tracks LLM citations.

Website Energizers

Website Energizers lists itself on Semrush as a growth-focused SEO team based in Banbury, Oxfordshire. That reads like a strong fit for SEO foundations.

Press on the AI search method. Ask what changes in its process for ChatGPT and Perplexity visibility.

Takeaway: treat a listing as a reason to book a call, then judge the agency on its answers.

Red flags and what to avoid

Some answers end the conversation early. Watch for these:

  • Guaranteed rankings. Nobody controls Google or an LLM’s output.
  • No technical audit. Content on a broken site is wasted spend.
  • Unedited AI content at scale. Thin pages damage trust with users and search systems.
  • Vanity reporting. Impressions and keyword counts with no conversion data.
  • No explanation of LLM visibility method. “We do GEO” is a label, not a process.
  • Directory-only credentials. A badge from a listing site proves the agency paid attention to its profile.

If you see two of these, walk away.

Takeaway: one red flag is a question; two are an answer.

How to run the shortlist

Shortlisted agency folders arranged for side-by-side review

Keep the process short and comparable. Run it like this:

  1. Write a one-page brief. State your goal (Google traffic, LLM citations, pipeline), your sector and your constraints.
  2. Ask for a sample audit. A short review of your site shows how the agency thinks before you pay.
  3. Test two agencies on the same question set. Use the vetting table word for word, then compare answers side by side.
  4. Check sector fit. SaaS, FinTech and Web3 buyers each face different review cycles and audiences.
  5. Decide on scope. Weigh an agency against building internally; Victoria Olsina’s piece on a Web3 SEO agency vs in-house sets out that trade-off.

SaaS founders should also read Victoria Olsina’s SaaS SEO agency guide before the first call.

Takeaway: same questions, same brief, two agencies. The gap shows quickly.

Conclusion

Choose on evidence. Technical foundations, a repeatable AI search method, controlled content, pipeline reporting and sector fit decide whether an agency moves traffic or just moves money.

If an agency feels like too much commitment, read Victoria Olsina’s guide on hiring an SEO consultant and compare the two routes before you sign.

FAQ

What does an AI SEO agency do?

An AI SEO agency improves a brand’s visibility in Google and in LLM-powered answers such as ChatGPT and Perplexity. It combines technical SEO, content strategy and AI search tracking to earn rankings and citations.

Do I still need technical SEO?

Yes. LLMs and Google both depend on pages they can crawl, index and parse. Without clean architecture, schema and indexation, AI search tactics have nothing reliable to build on, so fix the foundations first.

How do I check an agency’s AI search claims?

Ask for the exact prompts they would track and an example citation log. Then run a few of those prompts in ChatGPT and Perplexity yourself and compare the results with what the agency describes.

Should I pick an agency from a directory?

Use a directory to find names, not to choose. Directories sort by their own scores, listings or contacts tracked. Shortlist from them, then test every agency against the same criteria and questions.

What should I ask on a first call?

Ask how they audit technical SEO, how they track LLM citations, who edits AI-assisted content, what they report and how they handle your sector. Vague answers on any of these are a warning.

Get your brand cited in AI search

Victoria Olsina’s AI SEO and GEO service helps crypto, fintech and AI brands get ranked on Google and cited by ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews. Book a free strategy session to see where your brand stands in AI search today.

Ask questions about this post:

See more from this blog in your Google results.

Looking for an SEO strategy that aligns with your business goals?

Book a Free Consultation. Free 30 minute consultation.